Marcion, combining language soon used of the latter with conventional. Marcion wrote the antitheses to show the differences between the god of the old testament and the true god. As a result, eventually orthodox christianity defeated or merged with marcionism by the. To solve this antithesis, marcion invented the idea that christ had two. The road not taken by robert frost poetry foundation. About the middle of the second century 140155 he traveled to rome, where he joined the syrian gnostic cerdo marcion believed that jesus was the savior sent by god, and paul the apostle was his. An important but frequently forgotten episode in the early church was the movement founded by marcion near 144 a. Here is a question that has been raised about one of my posts. On the designation psychici, see our anti marcion, p. The ghost of marcion continues to do this in the church today. The gnostic writers forth these contrasts in his antitheses, and his adoption of a reduced new testament consisting of the gospel according to luke and certain epistles by the apostle paul, all purged of presumed jewish interpolations, had an important bearing on the churchs formation of. I agree with marcion in that the god of parts of the ot was an entirely different god than the one presented by jesus, but thats about as far as i agree with him.
About the middle of the second century 140155 he traveled to rome, where he joined the syrian gnostic cerdo. Marcion, the canon, the law, and the historical jesus chris price gilles quispel, marcion and the text of the new testament, vigiliae christianae 52. Marcions primary antithesis involved faith and law. The antithesis of marcion on early christian writings. In any event, this will at least provide the reader a general idea of what marcion s work antithesis may have been like. Tertullian part i june 2, 2015 may 18, 2015 jacob j. Part of a library of materials dealing with gnosis and gnosticism, both ancient and modern. Marcion believed there was one true gospel which had been corrupted into many versions.
Neoplatonism and gnosticism western esotericism perennial philosophy esoteric christianity theosophy carl jung gnosticism in modern times v t e. The evidence of marcion s gospel against an assumed marcionite redaction the historical study of early christianity continues to labor under the burden of assumptions carried over from traditional christian here siology. Having grown up in church all of my life, and having a fairly heavy exposure to mainstream christianity, and having familiarity with the bible, possibly you like i noticed that mainstream christianity often deemphasizes the old testament and puts a disproportionate amount of emphasis on pauls. He explained the corruption on the basis of galatians in which paul emphasizes that there is only one gospel and states that false brethren are attempting to turn believers from this gospel. Rhodo and tertullian, young men in marcions old age, described him as a mariner and a shipmaster respectively. It lies in the nature of the case that the spirit that is to exist as pure spirit must be an otherworldly one, for, since i am not it, it follows that it can only be outside me. The question begins with a quotation from what i said, in contrast to something else i said, which seems to contradict it. Marcionism was an early christian dualist belief system that originated in the teachings of marcion of sinope in rome around the year 144 marcion was the son of a bishop of sinope in pontus.
The antithesis radical rejection of judaism and all jewish scripture founded churches and taught people. There is therefore in most cases no one antithesis. Marcion s use of the christian canon brings him closer to the scriptureoriented christianity of the great councils than it does to the mythoriented gnostics. Contradictions between the old testament deity and the new testament god. Marcionism was an early christian dualist belief system that originated in the teachings of marcion of sinope in rome around the year 144. The gospel of marcion, called by its adherents the gospel of the lord, was a text used by the mid2nd century christian teacher marcion of sinope to the exclusion of the other gospels. We now present marcions case for the antithesis as. He understood how paul had reprimanded the church at galatia for much the same thing. Jesus only appeared to be human, much the way the angels seen by abraham appeared to be human gen. Antithesis contradictions between the old testament deity and the new testament god. Im going to get to the issue by means of a circuitous route, by talking about how that relationship was understood by followers of. Marcion and the text of the new testament by gilles quispel two recent publications drew my attention to a topic upon which i published many years ago, namely, the new testament text known to. The following is a link to a hypothetical reconstruction of his antithesis which is no longer extant. Marcion, the canon, the law, and the historical jesus a survey of marcion s life and legacy.
Marcion s most influential writing was a work entitled antithesis, described as a highly competent work which consisted of contrasted statements arranged to prove the incompatibility of the law and the gospel. The road not taken by robert frost about this poet robert frost was born in san francisco, but his family moved to lawrence, massachusetts, in 1884 following his fathers death. On one hand, there was the law given moses, which the apostolic twelve endorsed in matthews gospel. Heikki raisanen, marcion and the origins of christian antijudaism, temenos 33 1997. Aug 05, 2005 i am an admirer of marcion as well as arius. May 02, 20 the problem with marcion is in my view that he was a literalist, which is why i prefer the valentinian mythicism. Since, however, the divine authority and the nature of the case, and common sense, do not admit this insane position of the heretics, we have here the opportunity of putting in a veto in the briefest possible terms, on the substance of christs body, against marcion s phantoms. Heretics antinomianism antinomianism n t n m n z m n.
Jesus was speaking critically of jewish values and practices. Marcionismthe forgotten crisis overviewintroduction. Marcion, the son of the bishop of sinope a seaport of pontus along the black sea who had become a wealthy shipowner, stood before the presbyters to expound his teachings in order to win others to his point of view. Marcion s view of god marcion was a native of sinope in pontus of asia minor, a trading axis of the uppermediterranean and a crossroads of intellectual exchange. The reception of the canon by the modern church is inhibited, it. Ase 3212015 5587 markus vinzent marcions gospel and the beginnings of early. Mar 15, 2017 marcions canon actually had a positive side effect. The epistle of the apostle paul to the laodiceans pdf. Its reconstructed fragments now appear among the new testament apocrypha. The site includes the gnostic library, with the complete nag hammadi library and a large collection of other primary gnostic scriptures and documents. Gard the scriptures are collected in what is known as the it canon, that is, a grouping of writings received as authoritative and normative for faith and life. The reception of the canon by the modern church is inhibited, it seems to me, by functional marcionism. He was not only an extreme literalist, but also an extreme ascetic.
It is supposed to be an account of change through conflict. The marcionite bible the marcionite bible was assembled by marcion of sinope, sometime in the earlymid second century. Antenicene fathersvolume iiiantimarcionagainst praxeasi. Jason david beduhn the myth of marcion as redactor. Marcions pioneering role in establishing the earliest christian. Marcion s pre144 manuscript of paul what i shall call the premar cionite text of rome must have contained a number of marginal glosses, for one of them is signaled by tertullian, when discussing pauls interpreta tion gal. Antithesis, marcion attempted to expose the seemingly irresolvable conflicting natures of the supposedly unloving and inferior god of the old testament books versus the loving and superior god of the new testament books. The gnostic affinity or group identity was a secret bond that.
The bettering consisted in combining marcions gospel with the law and the. Ostensibly an attempt to recapture primitive christianity, this movement derives its name from marcion, a wealthy shipowner, son of a bishop, and probably a bishop himself, who arrived in rome around 140. The forums in the christian congregations category are now open only to christian members. Adolf harnack was a german theologian, scholar and historian. Marcion and the marcionites 144 3rd century ce at the end of july, 144 ce, a hearing took place before the clergy of the christian congregations in rome. Contradictions between the old testament diety and the new testament god.
Marcion was born toward the end of the first century in sinope, a city in pontus, on the southern coast of the bla. Marcions teaching was condemned as heresy in the year 144. In marcions book known as the antitheses, which exists only in fragments quoted by others, we find endorsement of everything pauline, including faith alone. Marcion sponsored an open christianity that met in churches. Marcion is often thought to have first established an explicit canon. Harnack presents marcion s historical significance. Marcion denied the resurrection of the body because flesh and blood cannot inherit the kingdom of god 1 cor.
Mainstream christianity has criticized believers for keeping the seventhday sabbath, for celebrating the biblical holy days, for practicing the dietary law, and for refusing to shave their beards things that god has commanded. The archheretic marcion, jesus, and the jewish law. The churchs scripture and functional marcionism ctsfw. Pdf marcions gospel and the beginnings of early christianity. Tertullian five books against marcion the ntslibrary. The church was still in its infancy, and it can be argued that marcionism was the most dangerous heresy yet to plague it. The evidence of marcions gospel against an assumed marcionite redaction the historical study of early christianity continues to labor under the burden of assumptions carried over from traditional christian here siology. Christian members please remember to read the statement of purpose threads for each forum within christian congregations before posting in the forum. Marcion is manifested today in contemporary views of god, scripture, and salvation. Marcion s teaching was condemned as heresy in the year 144. The problem with marcion is in my view that he was a literalist, which is why i prefer the valentinian mythicism.
Marcion and the roman church was the antithesis between jehovah and the heavenly father. This was essentially a list of irreconcilable differences that marcion saw between the two testaments. The sect which he founded spread widely, and was for a time a serious menace to the church. It is important because it explains the two gospels in the current new testament and why they were tolerated. I must emphasize that this is a loose presentation, in that i have not confined myself to citing only passages which appeared in marcion s canon, but have made free use of other canonical material as well. Marcionism was an early christian dualist belief system that originated in the teachings of. Marcion s major work was entitled antithesis and has not survived. The archheretic marcion, jesus, and the jewish law in this thread ive started to talk about the relationship of jesus to the law of moses. Marcion, the canon, the law, and the historical jesus.
Marcions scriptural canon, argues that marcion not only put together the very first christian canon of scriptures, he gave christianity very idea of doing so. After marcion commenced his evangelistic crusade, a significant portion of christian literature became devoted to apologetics. The five books against marcion online christian library. Ancient critics thought marcion cut out texts he didnt like from an already existing canon, but this is not true. There needed to be a distance between god and matter in marcion s thinking, so the creator god of the old testament was not a true god or he was a lesser god. Marcion affirmed jesus christ as the savior sent by god and paul as his chief apostle, but he rejected the hebrew bible and yahweh. Marcion s theology was dominated by the antithesis between the ot creator god of law the demiurge and jesus god of love and grace. The marcionite bible was not divided into old and new testaments like the modern bible, and was dramatically shorter. Marcion taught only paul had the correct gospel of jesus, i. These formulations helped crystallize the concept of orthodoxy or catholicism.
Oct 28, 20 marcion holds a lasting legacy for christians as the inventor of the new testament. Marcion was excommunicated from the roman church c. For details of the contents of the individual letters in marcion s apostolicon, see galatians, first corinthians, second corinthians, romans, firstthessalonians, secondthessalonians, ephesians, colossians, philemon, philippians, and laodiceans respectively as described in more detail here, marcion is considered to be the first person to have produced a collection of documents that are now. Epiphanius records in his panarion that marcion was born the son of a bishop in pontus in modernday turkey. The doctrine or belief that the gospel frees christians from required obedience to any law, whether scriptural, civil, or moral, and that salvation is attained solely through faith and the gift of.
The development of the canon of the new testament marcion. I recommend it for anyone who is put off by yahweh as much as i am. The outlines of harnacks landmark monograph on marcion are well known from summaries and discussions of it as well as through the german original. Among these is the fact that polycarp does not bother to name his enemy, and we still do not have the necessary irrefutable evidence to do it for him. Lukes gospel, selected by marcion as his authority, and mutilated by him. He understood paul to have rejected the old testament and its god by saying the reading of the old testament and moses.
Marcionism was a religious movement based on the teachings of the 2ndcentury heretic marcion of sinope. This statement may only denote a withdrawal from the communion of the. In other words, the original true church of god truly did combine faith in christ with. He based his view upon comparing the hebrew scriptures with the teachings of jesus and the apostle paul. The churchs scripture and functional marcionism daniel l.
Tillich states of the gnostics in general, and marcion in particular, that. Marcion preached that the god who sent jesus into the world was a different, higher deity than the creator god of judaism. Concerning the reconstruction of the first verse of the marcionite corpus paulinum, vigiliae christianae 42 1988. According to tertullian, the principal, and consequently the entire, matter of discussion is one in number, whether it is permissible to suggest the existence of two gods adv. Marcionism is the dualist belief system that originated in rome from the teachings of marcion of sinope around the year 144. A native of sinope in pontus, marcion came to rome c. The church also responded to marcions view of christ. He denied that christ was truly incarnate because flesh, like all matter, was the creation of yahweh and therefore evil. The marcionite bible was assembled by marcion of sinope, sometime in the earlymid second century. A note those who identify marcion as the false teacher against whom polycarp writes in his letter to the philippians continue to face difficult problems. Text and transmission from marcion to augustine, studies in judaism in late antiquity 121 1975. Marcion had bought into platos idea that matter is bad, and so, the god of the old testament, the god who created the world, was not a god that he could stomach. The gnostic affinity or group identity was a secret bond that transcended the local christian congregations.
The difference between the two christs, is that the jewish christ was ordained by the creator for the restoration of the people alone from its dispersion, while our christ was appointed by the supremely good god for the liberation of the whole human race. Harnack says that even if the opponents of marcion had captured every word of marcion in some form there would still be no way to restore antithesis because no one knows how the work was arranged. By cogwriter marcion was considered to have been the son of the bishop of sinope in pontus an area in what is now northwest turkey and born around 110 a. He believed paul had shown this antithesis the opposites of jehovahs law and the grace of god the father. But if you look at conflicting tendencies in reality, tendency a is often not just in conflict with nota but with a number of conflicting tendencies b, c, d, etc. Marcion, an avid disciple of paul, appeared on the seen determined to rescue the church from its judaic beliefs. Portrait of a heretic there is little doubt that the teachings of marcion and his followers represented a greater threat to orthodox christianity than any other heresy in the second century. Developing some eccentric theological views, he eventually taught that the god of the old testament was not the true god but rather that the true and higher god had been revealed only with jesus c.
996 912 1465 514 582 631 630 755 313 665 652 1294 1047 955 1446 69 588 986 1203 674 1371 1002 72 210 981 145 1470 119 649 1127 1374 444 267 572 390 989 1307 498 159 273 23 606 1320